Buying or selling a home is one of the biggest financial decisions most people ever make — and the realtor you choose has a real impact on how smoothly it goes, how much you pay (or get), and how much stress you're carrying by the end of it. Here's how to actually find a good one.
Start with a referral, not a Google search
The best realtors often don't need to advertise — they get repeat clients and referrals from friends, family, and past customers. Ask people you trust who recently bought or sold in your area, and ask them why they'd recommend that agent, not just whether they would. "They were nice" is a different answer than "they got us $30,000 under asking" or "they caught a problem in the inspection that saved us a fortune."
Look for experience and volume, not just a small territory
There's a common myth that you need an agent who only works one tiny neighborhood to get good advice. In reality, an agent who covers a wider area (like GTA West) and closes a high volume of transactions often brings more to the table, not less. Volume means pattern recognition — they've seen more inspections, more negotiations, more financing hiccups, and more deals fall apart and come back together than someone who only handles a handful of sales a year. A broader service area also means they can give you real comparisons between neighborhoods, not just tunnel vision on one street.
What actually matters is whether they can speak with confidence and specifics about the area you're looking in — pricing trends, how fast homes are moving, what's coming up in terms of development. Ask directly: "How many deals have you closed recently, and what does that experience look like in the area I'm interested in?" A high-volume agent with broad coverage can usually answer that better than a low-volume agent with a narrow one.
Check reviews — but read between the lines
Google reviews, Reddit, and Realtor.ca profiles are useful, but don't just look at the star rating. Read a handful of the actual reviews and look for patterns: Do people mention responsiveness? Negotiation skill? Communication during a stressful moment? One glowing review means little; five reviews all praising the same trait means a lot.
Interview more than one agent
Good realtors expect to be interviewed — it's a normal part of the process, not an insult. Ideally a preliminary meeting, or video call will give you a good starting point. Make sure to ask:
How will you communicate with me, and how often?
What's your strategy for this specific market right now?
Can you walk me through a recent deal that didn't go as planned, and how you handled it?
Are there any fees, rebates, or incentives I should know about?
How they answer matters as much as what they say. A good agent explains things clearly without jargon and doesn't rush you.
Make sure they're full-time and licensed
Real estate is a full-time job when done well. Ask how long they've been licensed and whether they do this full-time — an agent juggling it as a side gig is less likely to have the market knowledge or availability you need during a fast-moving deal.
Consider a cashback realtor in you’re Buying
Some realtors offer buyers a cashback rebate — a portion of their commission returned to you after closing. It's a legal, increasingly common practice, and worth understanding before you start your search.
Here's how it typically works: the buyer's agent commission is paid by the seller (built into the deal) as usual, but instead of keeping all of it, the agent rebates a percentage back to the buyer once the sale closes. Depending on the purchase price, that can mean thousands of dollars back in your pocket — money that can help cover closing costs, moving expenses, or renovations.
A few things worth asking if you're considering this route:
How is the cashback amount calculated, and when do I actually receive it?
Does the rebate affect the level of service I get?
Are there any conditions attached (minimum purchase price, financing type, etc.)?
The key is not to assume a cashback offer means a lesser agent. Some highly experienced, high-volume realtors offer cashback simply because their transaction volume lets them operate efficiently enough to pass savings along — the rebate is a byproduct of scale, not a discount on effort. As with any agent, the same rules apply: check their track record, ask for references, and make sure their communication style and experience are the right fit for you. The rebate should be a bonus on top of good service, not a replacement for it.
Trust your gut on communication style
Some people want texts and quick updates; others want a phone call and a detailed walkthrough. A great realtor for your neighbor might be the wrong fit for you simply because your communication styles clash. Pay attention to how they communicate during the very first conversation — that's usually how they'll communicate throughout the whole transaction.
The bottom line
The right realtor has real, demonstrated experience — whether that comes from deep roots in one neighborhood or broad, high-volume coverage across a region — communicates in a way that works for you, and comes recommended by people whose judgment you trust. If cashback is on the table, treat it as a nice bonus, not the deciding factor. Take the time to interview a few agents before you commit — it's the one interview that can save (or make) you tens of thousands of dollars.